Despite being practiced by various cultures and religions throughout history, being married to more than one person at a time, also known as polygamy, is illegal in many countries today, including the United States and most Western countries.
Polygamy, the practice of having multiple spouses at the same time, has been a controversial and widely debated topic for centuries.
In this blog post, we will explore the reasons behind the illegality of a polygamous marriage, its historical context, and the impact it has on society.
Polygamy has been practiced in various forms throughout history, with some cultures allowing both men and women to have multiple spouses (polygyny and polyandry, respectively).
In ancient societies, polygamy was often considered a practical solution to issues such as high infant mortality rates, low life expectancies, and a need for more laborers in agricultural societies.
However, as societies evolved and became more complex, the practice of polygamous marriage began to decline. The rise of Christianity and other monotheistic religions played a significant role in this decline, as they promoted monogamous relationships as the ideal form of marriage.
Although the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) was a notable example of a monotheistic belief system that supported multiple marriages, today, polygamy violates the church’s teachings, and they also ban polygamy.
Over time, monogamous marriages became the norm in most societies, and laws were put in place to enforce this standard. The US federal government outlawed polygamy in 1882 with the passage of the Edmunds Act.
Legal Reasons for the Illegality of Polygamy
There are several legal reasons why polygamy is illegal in many countries. Here are some of the primary factors:
Protecting Individual Rights
One of the main reasons for the illegality of polygamy is the potential for abuse and exploitation within polygamous relationships. In many cases, polygamous marriages involve one man with multiple wives, which can lead to unequal power dynamics and a lack of autonomy for the wives.
In such situations, women may be subjected to physical, emotional, or financial abuse by their husbands or even other wives. By prohibiting polygamy, governments aim to protect the rights and well-being of individuals, particularly women, who may be vulnerable in such relationships.
Ensuring Legal Equality
In most legal systems, marriage is a contract between two parties that grants certain rights and responsibilities. The legal recognition of polygamous marriages would complicate this system, as it would require the law to accommodate multiple spouses in areas such as inheritance, custody, and property rights.
By maintaining the illegality of polygamy, governments can ensure that all married couples have equal rights and protections under the law, avoiding potential disputes or complications that could arise from recognizing polygamous marriages.
Maintaining Social Order
Another reason for the illegality of polygamy is the potential for social unrest and conflict that might arise from its practice. In societies where polygamy is prevalent, there is often a shortage of available women for men to marry, which can lead to increased competition and tension between men.
This situation can result in higher rates of violence, crime, and social instability, as men may resort to aggressive or criminal behavior in order to secure a wife. By prohibiting polygamy, governments aim to maintain social order and minimize the potential for conflict and unrest that could stem from its practice.
Cultural and Religious Factors
While legal reasons play a significant role in the illegality of polygamy, cultural and religious factors also contribute to its prohibition. As mentioned earlier, many Western countries have a strong Christian heritage, which promotes monogamous relationships as the ideal form of marriage.
In addition to Christianity, other major world religions, such as Judaism and Islam, also have teachings that discourage or limit the practice of polygamy. For example, while Islam allows men to have up to four wives, it also stipulates that they must be treated equally and provided fairly, making it difficult for most men to meet these requirements.
Furthermore, in contemporary society, monogamous relationships are often seen as the ideal form of partnership, providing stability and emotional support for both partners. This cultural preference for monogamy further reinforces the illegality of polygamy, as it is seen as an outdated and potentially harmful practice.
The Impact of Polygamy on Society
While some argue that the prohibition of polygamy infringes on individual freedoms and the right to choose one’s marital arrangements, there are several negative consequences associated with the practice that must be considered.
While some may argue that polygamy is a matter of personal freedom, like same-sex marriage, these claims are dubious at best.
Impact on Women
As mentioned earlier, women in polygamous relationships often experience a lack of autonomy and may be subjected to abuse or exploitation.
Additionally, research has shown that women in polygamous marriages are more likely to suffer from mental health issues, such as depression and anxiety than those in monogamous relationships.
Moreover, polygamous marriages can also lead to economic disadvantages for women, as they often have limited access to education and employment opportunities. This lack of financial independence can make it difficult for women to leave abusive or unhappy marriages, further perpetuating their vulnerability.
Impact on Children
Children raised in polygamous families may also face unique challenges. Studies have shown that children from polygamous households are more likely to experience behavioral and emotional problems, as well as lower educational achievement, compared to those from monogamous families.
These outcomes may be due to a variety of factors, including the potential for favoritism or neglect by parents, competition for resources among siblings, and the overall instability that can result from having multiple spouses and children in a single household.
Impact on Society
As mentioned earlier, the practice of polygamy can lead to social unrest and instability, particularly in societies where there is a shortage of available women for men to marry. This situation can result in increased crime and violence, as well as strained community relations and a breakdown in social order.
While the issue of polygamy is complex and multifaceted, its illegality in many countries can be attributed to a combination of legal, cultural, and religious factors.
By maintaining the prohibition on polygamy, governments aim to protect individual rights, ensure legal equality, and maintain social order while also upholding the cultural and religious values that promote monogamous relationships as the ideal form of marriage.
As our understanding of relationships and family structures continues to evolve, it remains important for societies to consider the potential consequences of polygamy and weigh the benefits of maintaining its prohibition against the rights of individuals to choose their own marital arrangements.
If you are interested in learning more about why polygamy is illegal and alternative forms of dispute resolution, contact ADR Times for educational materials and training courses on mediation, negotiation, ethics, and more.
- Removal to Federal Court - June 2, 2023
- What Is a Change Order? - May 30, 2023
- What Is Preemption? - May 25, 2023